How Much Real Estate Tax Did Williston Avoid in 2026?

Williston is a private boarding school in Easthampton with an endowment of $67M and a budget of $44M per year. It owns $60M worth of real estate in Easthampton but, because it’s designated as a 501(c)(3) organization, it pays no tax on that property.

There’s a good article in the Hampshire Daily Gazette today about Williston’s financial relationship with the City of Easthampton.

One paragraph, in particular, caught my attention:

According to [Mayor Salem] Derby’s proposal to Williston, the school would owe about $867,000 a year in property taxes based on the fiscal 2025 tax rate. A Gazette review of Williston’s property values produced slightly different figures: about $803,000 for fiscal 2025 and $850,000 for fiscal 2026. The amount shifts each year with the tax rate and property valuations.

Different organizations have come up with different numbers for what Williston would pay in taxes were it not tax-exempt, but nobody has shared their work.

Without transparent calculations, it’s hard to understand who’s making mistakes or different assumptions, so I thought I’d calculate the number step by step so that everyone can get on the same page in terms of the facts.

Spoiler: Williston would owe $860,613.87 in taxes on its real estate if it were a taxable entity.

Williston’s tax-exempt real estate property

According to the Easthampton Assessor’s office, Williston owned 32 land parcels in Easthampton in the 2026 fiscal year.

One of Williston’s 32 properties, 9 Railroad St. (Tandem Bagels), is a commercial building, so it is not tax-exempt. Williston pays normal taxes on that property. Williston claims tax-exempt status on its remaining 31 land parcels.

Here are Williston’s tax-exempt land parcels in Easthampton:

Williston's tax-exempt parcels and their assessed values
Parcel IDAddressAssessed Value (Property Tax)
53_4330 CENTER ST$431,700.00
151_1120 GREENWOOD CT$3,628,700.00
144_49183 MAIN ST$1,132,800.00
144_48185 MAIN ST$1,828,200.00
144_46191 MAIN ST$598,800.00
144_47193 MAIN ST$700.00
144_722 PARK ST$439,200.00
144_1128 PARK ST$1,635,300.00
144_1237 PARK ST$16,211,400.00
144_1040-50 PARK ST$28,458,200.00
151_2690 PARK ST$387,400.00
156_56_1PARK ST$900.00
156_57PARK ST RR$264,200.00
156_65PARK ST RR$303,800.00
144_83 PAYSON AVE$378,500.00
144_95 PAYSON AVE$439,100.00
53_367 PAYSON AVE$435,300.00
53_379 PAYSON AVE$436,300.00
53_3811 PAYSON AVE$477,800.00
53_3915 PAYSON AVE$725,900.00
53_4017 PAYSON AVE$685,600.00
53_4119 PAYSON AVE$1,948,200.00
53_35PAYSON AVE$109,200.00
144_252 PAYSON LN$781,300.00
156_43TAFT AVE$118,800.00
156_44TAFT AVE$124,600.00
156_45TAFT AVE$117,400.00
156_46TAFT AVE$154,600.00
156_47TAFT AVE$154,600.00
156_48TAFT AVE$113,600.00
156_58TAFT AVE$432,800.00
Total$62,954,900.00

Williston’s 31 tax-exempt parcels have a combined assessed value of $62,954,900.

Note that parcels are not always single buildings. Williston owns an enormous plot of land between Main St. and Park St. that contains dozens of buildings:

Some Williston-owned land parcels, such as this one between Main St. and Park St. contain many buildings

How much would Williston owe in taxes?

Easthampton has a single tax rate for both commercial and residential properties, which makes the calculation fairly straightforward. Easthampton’s tax rate is $13.29 per $1,000 of value, or 1.329%.

Multiplying Williston’s total real estate property value by the tax rate, we get:

$62,954,900 × 1.329% = $836,670.62

Okay, so Williston would owe $836,670.62 in real estate taxes?

Yes, but there’s more.

Plus CPA taxes

If you check your real estate tax bill, you’ll see that you pay both real estate tax and a CPA tax. What’s that?

The CPA tax is the Community Preservation Act tax, which funds open spaces, affordable housing, and historical preservation in the city. The CPA tax is a 3% surcharge on our real estate tax, but the first $100k of value is tax exempt.

We can calculate how much Williston would pay in CPA tax by subtracting $100k from each parcel’s assessed value (without going below zero), then multiplying the remaining value by the real estate tax rate (1.329%) and by the CPA surcharge rate (3%).

Assessed values after the $100,000 CPA exemption
Parcel IDAddressAssessed Value (CPA)
53_4330 CENTER ST$331,700.00
151_1120 GREENWOOD CT$3,528,700.00
144_49183 MAIN ST$1,032,800.00
144_48185 MAIN ST$1,728,200.00
144_46191 MAIN ST$498,800.00
144_47193 MAIN ST$0.00
144_722 PARK ST$339,200.00
144_1128 PARK ST$1,535,300.00
144_1237 PARK ST$16,111,400.00
144_1040-50 PARK ST$28,358,200.00
151_2690 PARK ST$287,400.00
156_56_1PARK ST$0.00
156_57PARK ST RR$164,200.00
156_65PARK ST RR$203,800.00
144_83 PAYSON AVE$278,500.00
144_95 PAYSON AVE$339,100.00
53_367 PAYSON AVE$335,300.00
53_379 PAYSON AVE$336,300.00
53_3811 PAYSON AVE$377,800.00
53_3915 PAYSON AVE$625,900.00
53_4017 PAYSON AVE$585,600.00
53_4119 PAYSON AVE$1,848,200.00
53_35PAYSON AVE$9,200.00
144_252 PAYSON LN$681,300.00
156_43TAFT AVE$18,800.00
156_44TAFT AVE$24,600.00
156_45TAFT AVE$17,400.00
156_46TAFT AVE$54,600.00
156_47TAFT AVE$54,600.00
156_48TAFT AVE$13,600.00
156_58TAFT AVE$332,800.00
Total$60,053,300.00

The total valuation of Williston’s properties for CPA purposes is $60,053,300, so we can calculate that its CPA tax would be:

$60,053,300.00 × 1.329% × 3% = $23,943.25

Total

TaxAmount
Real estate taxes$836,670.62
Community Preservation Act (CPA) tax$23,943.25
Total$860,613.87

That means if Williston were not tax-exempt, it would have owed the city $860,613.87 in real estate and CPA taxes for the 2026 fiscal year.

This is still an undercount

Williston’s official assessed value is undervalued because it is not assessed as frequently as are taxable properties. If Williston were paying taxes or participating in a PILOT, its obligations would likely be higher than what I calculated above.

Easthampton assessor Martha Leamy has said at city meetings that her office has deprioritized assessments of Williston’s properties. There’s no incentive to invest resources in assessing properties when Williston pays the same amount regardless of the assessment: zero.

Raw data

Further reading